Justice Leslie H. Southwick

By Ivan Sanchez 

The practice of gerrymandering has long been a contentious issue, with racial gerrymandering emerging as a concerning facet of American politics. This deliberate manipulation of electoral district boundaries based on racial lines raises significant questions about the fairness and inclusivity of the democratic process.

Racial gerrymandering involves the intentional drawing of electoral districts to dilute the voting power of a particular racial or ethnic group. Instead of ensuring equal representation, it undermines the principles of fair and impartial elections. This practice has historically been employed to consolidate power, perpetuate discrimination, and disenfranchise minority communities. No where is this truer than in the American South where Black and other minority communities have been subject to egregious violations of their right to vote from literacy tests to poll taxes. 

While progress has been made in the past year in eliminating racial gerrymandering in the US South, it continues. A new decision from the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, in a panel made up of Judge Carolyn Dineen King, Judge Jennifer Elrod, and Judge Leslie H. Southwick with Southwick writing for the panel, allowed the redrawing of legislative lines to continue. 

Judge Southwick allowed the state of Louisiana the opportunity to redraw the lines writing “The district court is to conduct no substantive proceedings until the earliest of (1) the completion of legislative action, (2) notice indicating the Legislature will not create new districts, or (3) January 15, 2024.” The three-judge panel noted that “the district court did not clearly err in its necessary fact-findings nor commit legal error in its conclusions that the Plaintiffs were likely to succeed on their claim that there was a violation of Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act in the Legislature’s planned redistricting.” 

One of the most profound consequences of racial gerrymandering is its direct impact on minority representation in government. By strategically redrawing district lines, certain groups find their voting power diluted, making it more challenging for them to elect candidates who truly represent their interests. This not only undermines the democratic ideal of equal representation but also perpetuates systemic inequities.

The fight against racial gerrymandering is a critical component of the broader struggle for a truly representative democracy. As the nation becomes increasingly diverse, addressing and rectifying the impacts of racial gerrymandering is essential for ensuring that every citizen’s voice is heard and that the democratic process remains a beacon of fairness and equality.

Copyright 2023 TNTRIBUNE, All rights reserved.